Arbitration Clauses in Consumer Contracts
Many consumer contracts contain arbitration clauses, which may require disputes to be resolved through arbitration rather than in court. Arbitration provisions frequently appear in contracts involving vehicle purchases, financing agreements, credit services, and other consumer transactions. These clauses, and others like them, are becoming more commonplace in various industries. These clauses can affect how disputes are resolved and what rights consumers may have when problems arise. Understanding whether an arbitration clause applies — and how it may affect your legal options — often requires careful review of the contract language.
What is Arbitration?
Arbitration is a dispute resolution process in which a third party, known as an arbitrator, hears the dispute and issues a decision. Depending on the terms of the agreement, arbitration may be binding or non-binding.
​
Many consumer contracts require binding arbitration, meaning the arbitrator’s decision may be final and enforceable in court.
Where Arbitration is Often Found
Arbitration provisions may appear in different parts of a consumer contract. In vehicle transactions, for example, arbitration clauses are commonly found in:
• the vehicle purchase agreement
• retail installment finance agreements
• stand-alone arbitration agreements
• warranty or service contracts
​
Consumers should review all documents associated with a transaction, including both the front and back pages, where arbitration provisions and other contractual terms are often located. An experienced consumer advocate can also identify and analyze these provisions. Depending on where they are found, how they were agreed upon, and the specific terms, an attorney may opine if the clause is enforceable, to whom it applies, and how. Only then can you fully appreciate the application and potential consequences to your particular case.
Other Contract Provisions that May Affect
Consumer Rights
Contracts that include arbitration clauses may also contain other provisions affecting how disputes are handled. These may include:
• class action waivers
• jury trial waivers
• limitations on damages
• forum selection provisions
​
Understanding how these provisions interact can be important when evaluating your options.
Different Types of Arbitration
Arbitration agreements can vary significantly. Important differences may include:
• binding vs. non-binding arbitration
• the arbitration forum administering the dispute
• the rules governing the arbitration process
• cost allocation between the parties
Arbitration vs. Court Litigation
Arbitration may differ from court litigation in several ways. Depending on the agreement and the dispute, arbitration may:
• proceed more quickly than court litigation
• limit discovery
• be conducted through private hearings rather than public court proceedings
• be decided by one person
​
Some of these factors have both pros and cons, and you may benefit from discussing them and their likely impact on your case with experienced counsel.
Experience with Consumer Arbitration
Wells Law has extensive experience representing consumers in arbitration proceedings involving automobile warranty disputes, consumer contracts, and other consumer protection matters.
During the COVID-19 pandemic shutdown, we arbitrated nearly 200 automobile defect and warranty cases, thereby providing the firm with substantial experience navigating manufacturer dispute-resolution programs and arbitration procedures.
Free Case Review
If you have been told your dispute must proceed through arbitration, Wells Law offers free case reviews to determine whether a matter may be appropriate for representation by our firm. During the case review process, we may help identify whether an arbitration provision appears to be involved and discuss how that may affect potential representation options through our office. Please note that an in-depth document review or legal analysis of your arbitration clause is not part of the free case review process.
​
If representation is offered, the arbitration provision and related contractual terms will be evaluated more fully in the context of the engagement.